« Perfectly Absurd | Main | Healthy Costs» Don Boudreaux
September 25, 2004
Hoppe-ing Mad
Don Boudreaux
Among the strangest and most convoluted arguments I’ve ever encountered is Hans-Hermann Hoppe’s allegedly free-market case for restricting immigration. Here’s his latest.
No single blog entry can do justice to this issue, so I’ll content myself with making two points. Before doing so, let me confess to being a proponent of open borders of the sort that the United States had until the 1880s (when racist Chinese-exclusion statutes were enacted).
First, if it were empirically true that the bulk of immigrants suck on the tit of the welfare state, then the solution most consistent with liberty is to permit a foreigner to enter on condition that he or she not be eligible for government welfare payments.
But I doubt very seriously that immigrants live at taxpayers’ expense. Julian Simon’s research (admittedly now somewhat dated) finds that immigrants are net tax payers. The same is true of George Borjas, here, who is less enthusiastic about immigration than was Simon.
Relatedly, if the concern with immigration were truly that too many immigrants live as welfare recipients, then immigration regulations would not focus, as they do, on forcibly keeping immigrants out of the labor force. (See my earlier post.)
Second, and much more importantly, by lamenting the fact that many immigrants are low-skilled, Hoppe seems to be ignorant of the principle of comparative advantage. When a low-skilled immigrant works, he produces net value – the economy becomes more productive. His employer is better off, he is better off, and consumers are better off. Nothing whatsoever in economic theory suggests that only “well-heeled, highly value-productive immigrants” enhance economic progress.
A few years ago I wrote these two columns in response to Hoppe's arguments, first here, then here. And Tom Palmer has a wonderful response to Hoppe’s latest confused musings on immigration.
.......
Of course, perhaps I am, as Hoppe would assert, “arrested in this phase of mental development.” But at least I’m aware of the principle of comparative advantage.
Posted by Don Boudreaux in Myths and Fallacies | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834518ccc69e200d83457206c69e2
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Hoppe-ing Mad:
» Cafe Hayek from tomgpalmer.com
Don Boudreaux has a short posting on l’Affaire Hoppe. (It’s on the quite educational site that he and Russell Roberts run, www.cafehayek.com.)... [Read More]
Tracked on Sep 25, 2004 10:47:42 AM
» What the Hoppe? from Obernews
Footnote 23 of Natural Order, the State, and the Immigration Problem was recently published over at Lewrockwell.com. Now it's been replaced by this. I haven't read much of Hoppe's work, so I can't critique him, but I've always been mystified [Read More]
Tracked on Sep 26, 2004 10:02:59 PM
» Monday's Daily News from The Club for Growth Blog
Relevant News and Commentary A National Sales Tax? GREAT IDEA! - Herman Cain, AJC Who’ll Head Fed Post-Greenspan? - N. Henderson, Wash Post One Cheer for the Tax Extender Package - R. Hederman, Heritage The Escalation of Income - A.... [Read More]
Tracked on Sep 27, 2004 10:18:46 AM
» Johan Norberg over Hoppe: from N i e k l o g
[Read More]
Tracked on Feb 4, 2005 7:52:53 AM
» Johan Norberg over Hoppe: from N i e k l o g
[Read More]
Tracked on Feb 4, 2005 7:53:25 AM
» Generic viagra cialis from Female ingestion of viagra
Raped big cock Asian cunts in rape and bondage Girls getting raped movies free Free video previews fantasy rape[Read More]
Tracked on Oct 11, 2005 1:08:49 PM
» Full Albums Archive from MP3 Album Finder
Enter Artist or Song or Album name to search: ... Download VA - –усска€ коллекци€ 4 «олотой шл€гер 70 х (1973 1979) mp3 ... [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 5, 2006 11:25:30 AM
» Finance Search Online: home insurance 2buk from Business Finance Online
Business Finance Online Product/Service Directory. Search for business finance related products and services by browsing the directory of business finance ... [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 28, 2006 4:49:20 AM
» Feds lower boom on Hu's Falun Gong heckler from Bush and Chinese
Bush and Chinese President Hu Jintao - hitting her with a federal charge that carries [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 28, 2006 5:16:18 PM
» Europages, European directory from Open Directory Project
Multilingual european business directory, 600000 european companies, european company directory and business opportunities, trade leads, ... [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 28, 2006 6:22:26 PM
» Library of Congress WWW/Z39.50 Gateway from Harvard Seismology: Centroid Moment Tensor Catalog
Contents: Search Library of Congress Catalog | Search Other Catalogs | About the Z39.50 ... Library of Congress Online Catalog. Simple Search (any keyword) ... [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 29, 2006 8:35:56 PM
» Pacers' Stojakovic Inactive for Game 2 vs. Nets from first-round playoff
was surprisingly inactive for Game 2 of Indiana's first-round playoff series against the New Jersey Nets on Tuesday night. [Read More]
Tracked on May 7, 2006 5:03:37 PM
» Jewelry Shop from Jewelry making, Tips from The Jeweler's bench - Jewelry making
The Gem and Jewelry World's foremost Resource on The Internet. ... The Jeweler's Selected Bibliography. Add Ganoksin Power Search to your website ...
[Read More]
Tracked on May 19, 2006 11:43:13 PM
» Italian Charms from ItalianCharms -- Search results
Italian charms has stainless links from companies by Zoppini, Boxing, ReFlorence, Puzzle, Ryry, Talexia & Unodomani... [Read More]
Tracked on May 21, 2006 4:59:26 PM
» Wade Still Battling Illness from attended practice,
infection, Miami guard Dwyane Wade did not work out with the Heat on Tuesday. Wade attended practice, 'but didn't do anything [Read More]
Tracked on Jun 18, 2006 11:03:40 AM
» equity loan
from estate loan real
Loans Home Equity Loans - Home Mortgage Student Loans [Read More]
Tracked on Jun 18, 2006 2:53:38 PM
» Congress Stuck in Immigration Stalemate from within the GOP,
the lack of bipartisan cooperation and splits within the GOP, passage of immigration [Read More]
Tracked on Jun 28, 2006 7:40:59 AM
