« Is Protection Unconstitutional? | Main | Evidently, it was not the sushi» Russell Roberts
December 07, 2004
More on Blue-State Creationism
Don Boudreaux
A few days ago I was inspired by Tom Palmer’s incisive review of Cass Sunstein’s latest book to point out that many “blue-staters” – Americans who think of themselves as “progressive,” rational, and “reality-based” – are also creationists. Not biological creationists, but creationists nevertheless – “social constructivists,” as Hayek called them.
At the blog The Panda’s Thumb several commenters misunderstand my point. Whenever an author is misunderstood, it’s the author’s fault. I try below to clarify.
…………..
One view of the origin of order is the design view – the creationist view. For example, fundamentalist Christians believe that all life on Earth is the result of conscious creation by a deity. Human beings’ opposing thumbs resulted from a (higher) mind’s plan and action, and the absence of hen’s teeth and horse’s toes likewise is the result of conscious design. Without such design, chaos and disorder would reign.
The non-creationist view – represented most compellingly by the theory of natural selection – explains how wonderfully intricate, useful, and orderly biological structures can and do emerge unplanned.
Creationist views (there are several variations) differ from non-creationist views by insisting that all order ultimately is the result of some design acting upon the whole.
Just as there is a compelling non-creationist view of biological beings, there is a compelling non-creationist view of social order. And while obviously different in detail, at a general level these two non-creationist theories share much with each other, not least of which is the scientific insistence that order is best explained, not by positing a creator, but by understanding the logic of an order’s emergence from small, individual acts, no one of which is “intended to” (or “intends” itself) to become part of a larger order. (And remember, Adam Smith offered his “invisible hand” theory a century before Darwin offered his.)
The “social” creationists are well and ably represented by Cass Sunstein who argues that peace and security and (hence) property rights and market exchange are impossible without an effective system of law. Because, in Sunstein’s view, the state is the producer of law, the state is ultimately responsible for our property and prosperity.
I’m prepared to argue that law can, and has been, ably produced and enforced without the state. (See, for example, Bruce Benson's superb book The Enterprise of Law.) But let’s put that issue aside and grant Sunstein his claim that only the state can produce and enforce law. Because no reasonable person doubts that law is indeed necessary for a prosperous society, Sunstein concludes that each of us owes our prosperity to the state. It’s a fair interpretation of Sunstein’s argument that the state creates society.
People such as Sunstein who believe that sovereign power is responsible for everything remind me of other people who thank God for their good fortune – for the roofs over their heads, for the food on their tables, for the good grades they got on the exam.... as if the roof over someone’s head had everything to do with the good graces of a deity and nothing whatsoever to do with the actions of the owner of the house or with the actions of thousands of other people, each of whom contributed in some little way to making that roof a reality.
So the state protects me from thieves and built the highway that I use to transport my goods to market. I’m grateful. But what about the farmer who grew the food to feed the trucker who drives the truck carrying my goods to market – and grew the food to feed the politicians who keep the state going? What about the oil-rig worker who helped to extract oil from the ground to be turned into gasoline to power the truck – and to power the limos in DC and the police cars in Denver? What about the engineer who helped design the engine that powers the truck and the limos and the police cars? What about the clerk at the convenience store who sells the trucker the coffee that helps to keep him awake on his drive?
In a market economy, even the most mundane good or service requires for its production and distribution the efforts of millions of people. Many of these individual tasks are utterly necessary for that good’s existence, but none of these individual tasks – including that of the state – is sufficient. There’s nothing special about the state.
Civility, high wages, economic growth, ingenious engineers, clean neighborhoods, excellent education, health care, baseball stadiums – you name it, it probably can be (and probably has been) produced by private efforts. Government can certainly affect the production and distribution of things – and reasonable people can argue about whether that effect is likely to be beneficial or not. But even if government’s services are necessary for our prosperity, it does not follow that government creates that prosperity.
….
Stated baldly, this proposition will attract few detractors – except the likes of Sunstein. But “blue-state creationism” is nevertheless rampant. Consider this letter to the editor in today’s NY Times:
Like Thomas L. Friedman, I was shocked to read that Congress cut financing for the National Science Foundation.
The United States is at a crucial turning point now in regard to scientific leadership in the world. We can either invest as much money as possible in supporting groundbreaking research benefiting nearly every aspect of our lives - training new scientists and engineers, improving science education and ensuring that the United States remains the best place in the world to pursue a career in science - or we can dedicate that money to frivolous pork, losing our place as the world leader in science and engineering.
As a graduate of Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology, I was instilled with the belief that science is vitally important to our society.
It's unfortunate that Congress hasn't learned the same lesson; the security of our nation, as well as our economic health, depends on it.
In other words, without taxpayer-financed scientific research, we’ll enjoy neither national security nor economic well-being.
NSF funding might or might not be justified. (I personally don’t think it’s justified, but that’s not my point.) The claim that this reader (and columnist Thomas Friedman) make is that genuine scientific advance can be created only by government. It's a creationist myth.
Posted by Don Boudreaux in Myths and Fallacies | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834518ccc69e200d83422250a53ef
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference More on Blue-State Creationism:
» Mo Blues from Crumb Trail
Don Boudreaux says much More on Blue-State Creationism, discussed earlier here. It's too good, too long and too important to excerpt. I recommend it to you.... [Read More]
Tracked on Dec 7, 2004 5:19:49 PM
» The Other Creationism from Duophony
Don Boudreaux has this and the original statement of the position, that progressives are creationists, too. But the bluest blue-state left-"liberal"atheist oughtn't be too quick with the self-congratulatory praise of his or her own rational faculties. ... [Read More]
Tracked on Dec 12, 2004 5:56:03 AM
» Statism is not creationism from Universal Acid
[The analogy between statism and creationism] is intended to sting people like me - committed Darwinians who despise creationism yet are left-liberals also committed to the use of state power to improve society. Fortunately for me though, the analogy... [Read More]
Tracked on Dec 13, 2004 7:40:44 PM
» Is Cass Sunstein a creationist? from The Panda's Thumb
Don Boudreaux thinks so. Update: Dr. Boudreaux explains further.... [Read More]
Tracked on Feb 7, 2005 10:42:13 AM
» Links Catalog Search Results For: renese from Public Library - Health - Drugs & Medicines
Search the Web:. OneBigVillage Home! Search the Web! Check Your Village Mail! Chat Now! ... Over the Counter (0). Prescription Drugs (0) Painkillers ... [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 8, 2006 2:55:35 AM
» Sue Somethin' from ritney considers
ritney considers legal action over Sean Preston's high-chair tumble. [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 27, 2006 2:37:40 AM
» Auto Search: 1934 chevrolet body wood chart from Online Auto Guise
Search and Compare Certified Pre-Owned Cars. Car Shopping Tools and Advice · 2006 Auto Shows · New York Auto Show Check out 2007 models and cool concepts ... [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 28, 2006 4:17:03 AM
» Europages, European directory from Open Directory Project
Multilingual european business directory, 600000 european companies, european company directory and business opportunities, trade leads, ... [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 29, 2006 1:45:01 PM
» Library of Congress WWW/Z39.50 Gateway from Harvard Seismology: Centroid Moment Tensor Catalog
Contents: Search Library of Congress Catalog | Search Other Catalogs | About the Z39.50 ... Library of Congress Online Catalog. Simple Search (any keyword) ... [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 30, 2006 10:42:15 AM
» Nets-Pacers Game 2 Notebook from back on track,
got back on track, but the Nets win on Tuesday started with their defensive energy. Hawks forward Josh Smith thinks that [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 30, 2006 12:10:27 PM
» SmartPhone Today: Everex E960 from Smartphone Reviews; Best SmartPhones
The Internet's 3rd Party information center for SmartPhone Shareware, SmartPhone Freeware, Reviews, Hardware, Discussion, and more! Updated Daily... [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 30, 2006 10:46:37 PM
» No Spin Here: Shaq Looks Like Real Deal from O'Neal on Thursday
a score that defined the Bulls' hopes in this first-round playoff series with the Miami Heat. [Read More]
Tracked on May 17, 2006 3:09:30 AM
» College Opportunities Online Locator from Search the Web
Search by criteria. Search by location, program, or both. By Location - Select up to 12 States or a Geographic Region ... [Read More]
Tracked on May 21, 2006 4:49:10 AM
» Dictionary Search Page from Dictionary Search
An unabridged dictionary from aalii to zymurgy, including a pronunciation guide... [Read More]
Tracked on May 22, 2006 2:57:55 PM
» Computer Simulations Help Nations Prepare for Flu Pandemic from models, a team
flu outbreak. The analysis, conducted by researchers at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Imperial [Read More]
Tracked on May 24, 2006 1:55:13 PM
» BabyBoomerTrips.com Launches Affiliate Program -- 'Forging Partnerships for Mutual Success' from through BabyBoomerTrips.com
is enabling website owners to earn additional revenue through their sites or blogs. (PRWEB [Read More]
Tracked on May 28, 2006 2:09:05 PM
» Chelsea offer Carlos a three-year contract from claimed that
that he has been offered a three-year contract by Premiership champions Chelsea. [Read More]
Tracked on Jun 6, 2006 9:19:43 AM
» Internal Audit: Resources for Internal Auditors from Audit Company
Internal Audit - is the Web portal and online community for the internal audit profession provides free audit work programs, ICQ's, checklists, ...
[Read More]
Tracked on Jun 7, 2006 10:36:02 AM
» Congress reaches deal on Iraq, hurricane funds
(Reuters)
from
and hurricane
bill to fund wars
and hurricane rebuilding after stripping billions of dollars in
projects [Read More]
Tracked on Jun 10, 2006 4:19:49 PM
» Siblings Coping With Autism from orkshops Help
orkshops Help Kids Share the Pain of Dealing With Disabilities [Read More]
Tracked on Jun 13, 2006 4:24:30 AM
» consolidation loan school
from loan payday
Loans Home Equity Loans - Home Mortgage Student Loans [Read More]
Tracked on Jun 18, 2006 7:26:13 PM
» UK police in appeals over Cumbria attacks from are appealing
appealing for information about a serious sexual assault on a number of young girls in Cumbria that they believe may have been carried [Read More]
Tracked on Jun 29, 2006 12:49:12 AM
» Netscape DevEdge Back Online from being offline
offline for about fifty days, Netscape DevEdge is back online (as of today at noon, Mozilla time).
Mitchell Baker, [Read More]
Tracked on Jul 24, 2006 3:31:50 PM
