« Cato University | Main | On Foreign Holders of U.S. Debt» Don Boudreaux
March 30, 2005
It's nearly over
Russell Roberts
The human race is about to go extinct taking everything down with it. Unfortunately, science has already died.
The headline in the Guardian:
Two-thirds of World's Resources 'Used Up'
Only a third left. What does that mean exactly? Let's turn to the article.
The human race is living beyond its means. A report backed by 1,360 scientists from 95 countries - some of them world leaders in their fields - today warns that the almost two-thirds of the natural machinery that supports life on Earth is being degraded by human pressure.
The study contains what its authors call "a stark warning" for the entire world. The wetlands, forests, savannahs, estuaries, coastal fisheries and other habitats that recycle air, water and nutrients for all living creatures are being irretrievably damaged. In effect, one species is now a hazard to the other 10 million or so on the planet, and to itself.
"Human activity is putting such a strain on the natural functions of Earth that the ability of the planet's ecosystems to sustain future generations can no longer be taken for granted," it says.
Pretty frightening stuff. What's the evidence for this extraordinary pessimism at a time when life expectancies in almost every area of the world are at all time highs?
· Because of human demand for food, fresh water, timber, fibre and fuel, more land has been claimed for agriculture in the last 60 years than in the 18th and 19th centuries combined.
· An estimated 24% of the Earth's land surface is now cultivated.
· Water withdrawals from lakes and rivers has doubled in the last 40 years. Humans now use between 40% and 50% of all available freshwater running off the land.
· At least a quarter of all fish stocks are overharvested. In some areas, the catch is now less than a hundredth of that before industrial fishing.
· Since 1980, about 35% of mangroves have been lost, 20% of the world's coral reefs have been destroyed and another 20% badly degraded.
· Deforestation and other changes could increase the risks of malaria and cholera, and open the way for new and so far unknown disease to emerge.
Look at that last item again:
· Deforestation and other changes could increase the risks of malaria and cholera, and open the way for new and so far unknown disease to emerge.
That is not science. That's scare-mongering. Or wild-guessing. Or something else. But it's not science. Is that from the journalist or the report? Alas, it's more or less from the report. Here's how the press release words it:
The degradation of ecosystem services could grow significantly worse during the first half of this century and is a barrier to achieving the UN Millennium Development Goals. In all the four plausible futures explored by the scientists, they project progress in eliminating hunger, but at far slower rates than needed to halve number of people suffering from hunger by 2015. Experts warn that changes in ecosystems such as deforestation influence the abundance of human pathogens such as malaria and cholera, as well as the risk of emergence of new diseases. Malaria, for example, accounts for 11 percent of the disease burden in Africa and had it been eliminated 35 years ago, the continent’s gross domestic product would have increased by $100 billion.
When you read the actual press release rather than the news story, you realize that we've left the realm of science and are somewhere else. 'Could grow worse.' 'Four plausible futures.' (Only four?) And they're worried about malaria's impact on GDP? But we could have saved millions of lives from death by malaria by using DDT. But that's bad for the environment. So is that good or bad?
Look at the first two items:
· Because of human demand for food, fresh water, timber, fibre and fuel, more land has been claimed for agriculture in the last 60 years than in the 18th and 19th centuries combined.
· An estimated 24% of the Earth's land surface is now cultivated.
Sounds scary. But why go back 60 years? Is 24% the critical number where the whole system is going to collapse? Why? Where's the evidence? I'm trying to find a reliable source on the web for what has happened since 1960. Most sources suggest that land under cultivation has risen from 1.3 billion hectares in 1960 to about 1.4 billion hectares today. (In the meanwhile, I'm searching for a reliable link.) If true, not so scary.
Water could be a problem down the road. It's a problem now around the world due to poorly run thugocracies around the world, but that's not what the report is referring to. The world's fisheries are probably mismanaged. But where's the evidence that we're standing on the edge of a precipice? There isn't any.
I plan to sleep well tonight, though I am worried about the state of science.
Posted by Russell Roberts in Environment | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834518ccc69e200d834231b0b53ef
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference It's nearly over:
» Darwin's Blade from Crumb Trail
I had felt some obligation to comment on the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment report recently released and commented on widely, but had been avoiding the task since it would just be another debunking of politicized craparooney based on a well... [Read More]
Tracked on Mar 30, 2005 6:41:14 PM
» Darwin's Blade from Crumb Trail
I had felt some obligation to comment on the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment report recently released and commented on widely, but had been avoiding the task since it would just be another debunking of politicized craparooney based on a well... [Read More]
Tracked on Mar 30, 2005 7:19:34 PM
» Saving the world from ourselves from In the Agora
The Millennium Ecosystem Assessment project hit the news yesterday with a lot of fanfare. Scores of media outlets featured the report on the front pages and plenty of blogs got in on the act as well. It reports that up... [Read More]
Tracked on Mar 31, 2005 12:09:37 PM
» Everything is running out, buy while stocks last from Samizdata.net
The Guardian newspaper reports that two-thirds of the world's resources have been "used up", so with only a third left, the crunch cannot be far away for Planet Earth. (Let's hope Hollywood is on the case). The splendid Cafe Hayek blog nicely chews up ... [Read More]
Tracked on Mar 31, 2005 3:53:05 PM
» The End Is Not Near from Citizen Z
Here's a link to the The Millenium Ecosystem Assessment, the report that has many in a flutter over the ... [Read More]
Tracked on Mar 31, 2005 8:51:40 PM
» Saving the world from ourselves from In the Agora
The Millennium Ecosystem Assessment project hit the news yesterday with a lot of fanfare. Scores of media outlets featured the report on the front pages and plenty of blogs got in on the act as well. It reports that up... [Read More]
Tracked on Mar 31, 2005 11:54:25 PM
» Fisker's Whiskers II from The Word Unheard
Week Two of The Fisker's Whiskers brings us another good selection of fiskings. One thing that has been learned in the process: Finding a really good fisking is a difficult endeavor as it appears harder to find when looking for... [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 5, 2005 4:06:13 PM
» Fisker's Whiskers II from The Word Unheard
Week Two of The Fisker's Whiskers brings us another good selection of fiskings. One thing that has been learned in the process: Finding a really good fisking is a difficult endeavor as it appears harder to find when looking for... [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 5, 2005 4:07:56 PM
» Fisker's Whiskers II from The Word Unheard
Week Two of The Fisker's Whiskers brings us another good selection of fiskings. One thing that has been learned in the process: Finding a really good fisking is a difficult endeavor as it appears harder to find when looking for... [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 5, 2005 4:14:24 PM
» Find search engines across the world with Search Engine Colossus from Meta-Search
Gain quick, efficient access to search engines from countries around the world with Search Engine Colossus - International Directory of Search Engines... [Read More]
Tracked on May 26, 2006 12:48:00 PM
