« Pricing Water | Main | Paul Krugman, Libertarian» Russell Roberts
April 01, 2005
Starving in the Streets
Russell Roberts
I think the world would be a better place if government got out of the retirement business altogether and let us take of ourselves rather than have the government treat us like children, incapable of dealing with the complexities of risk and reward.
There are two different philosophical arguments against the idea of people taking care of themselves. One view argues that government provision of social security is simply better because it is a contract between the generations where we all take responsibility for one another. To me this is romance at best or a hoax or a fraud at worst. What does it mean to say we all take responsibility for one another? A family of 300 million people isn't a family. And somehow I lose all the romance when poor workers are taxed to support wealthy retirees. I just don't get it.
In the romantic view of government, collective provision of things is always better than private provision. My favorite example of this comes from a New York Times review of Thomas Frank's One Market Under God a few years back:
At one point Frank discusses the proposition that Peter Lynch deserves middle-class hero status because people stop him on the street to thank him for running the popular Fidelity Magellan Fund so well that it allowed them to accumulate a bigger retirement nest egg, or to pay for their kid's tuition, or to build an addition to their home. Frank of course sees no heroism in this, and counters that ''each of these necessities -- pensions, shelter, college -- were things Americans had once sought to ensure through union activity or government intervention, things that Americans once believed were theirs simply by virtue of being citizens, things that could and should be available to everyone in a democratic society.''
At one level this is simply romantic nostalgia. At another level it is delusion, thinking that somehow being a citizen generates these benefits without an understanding of the process that actually produces them. I don't think Peter Lynch is a hero. But even in Frank's romantic vision where government was once a source of material well-being, the government wasn't producing the well-being, it was redistributing it from someone who was doing the actual work. Portraying the government as heroic provider is an intellectual dishonesty unless we're talking about Cuba, say, where life is simpler, poorer and more static.
But there is another argument against personal responsibility that I find even more mystifying. In this argument, without government provision of something, it simply would not exist. When I write or talk on getting government out of the retirement business, some people inevitably email me telling me that in my ideal world, poor seniors would starve in the streets because social security wouldn't be there to take care of them.
One of the problems with this argument is that it ignores the fact that poor young people have a tougher time because they are forced to pay for social security. But the deeper problem with it is the presumption that without government, it simply would not get done. In this view, without government schools, there would be no education. Without government food stamps, there would be no aid to the poor. Without the post office, no letters would get delivered.
This lack of imagination ties in to the earlier romance about government. It ignores the private communities, the private ties, the voluntary associations we make that make our lives satisfying and make the world a better place. It ignores that when government acts, it crowds out voluntary kindness and replaces it with a more sterile version. Yes, it can be hard because of free-rider problems to voluntarily solve social problems. But it is harder, not impossible. And the quality of the care that results is often better.
Think of the myriad of small good deeds we do and receive from others that make life civilized—holding a door open for someone whose arms are full of packages, pushing a stranger's car out of a snow bank, giving blood, adopting a child. These countless acts of kindness happen without collective action by government because the costs of a government doorman who springs into action when someone comes by carrying groceries would be too expensive. But forget the cost issue. Isn't it lovely to hold the door, to give to charity, to comfort the fallen? Noticing that in the world around us, these good deeds happen without government may give some solace to the worriers who think that without social security, elderly poor people would starve to death.
I've been thinking about this since watching an EBay commercial. (Go here. In the left hand margin find the menu for "TV Spots" and choose "Belief.")
Finally, Bastiat, in The Law wrote eloquently on the lack of imagination I'm discussing here:
Do those worshippers of government believe that free persons will cease to act? Does it follow that if we receive no energy from the law, we shall receive no energy at all? Does it follow that if the law is restricted to the function of protecting the free use of our faculties, we will be unable to use our faculties? Suppose that the law does not force us to follow certain forms of religion, or systems of association, or methods of education, or regulations of labor, or regulations of trade, or plans for charity; does it then follow that we shall eagerly plunge into atheism, hermitary, ignorance, misery, and greed? If we are free, does it follow that we shall no longer recognize the power and goodness of God? Does it follow that we shall then cease to associate with each other, to help each other, to love and succor our unfortunate brothers, to study the secrets of nature, and to strive to improve ourselves to the best of our abilities?
Posted by Russell Roberts in Cooperation | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834518ccc69e200d8345c695e69e2
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Starving in the Streets:
» Jackson, Lakers Hope There's No Place Like Home from 10 of their last
13 games at Staples Center, including the final five of the regular season. [Read More]
Tracked on Mar 25, 2006 5:54:51 AM
» MP3 File Search from The Mp3Database
Download mp3 audio music and song lyrics. Mp3 search engine to music links for free download ... Quick Database Search search in 250209 mp3 entries ...
[Read More]
Tracked on Mar 26, 2006 2:43:04 AM
» MP3 Downloads, Full Albums, Latest Hits, MP3 Search from Global Media Search Engine
Big Mp3 Archive, Mp3 Search, Mp3 Albums, Mp3 Songs, Mp3 Software, Mp3 Traffic Exchange, Advertising... [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 5, 2006 4:00:24 AM
» Cell Phones from mobilebum.info
News and ... Sep News of Safety phones, new cell phone phones Cell time ... [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 8, 2006 3:50:27 AM
» Most popular words 2006: from Reader's Favorites at Scientific American
The articles includes Editor's Favorites, top e-mailed stories, and most popular articles. ... Babies Can Learn Words as Early as 10 Months ... [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 12, 2006 9:16:00 PM
» Drugs & Supplements from Drug Information and Supplement Information
Search: Enter a drug name ... LEGAL CONDITIONS AND TERMS OF USE APPLICABLE TO ALL USERS OF THIS SITE. ANY USE OF THIS SITE CONSTITUTES YOUR AGREEMENT TO ... [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 13, 2006 8:54:02 PM
» Moblie Phones,Cell Phone Dictionary from Dictionary of Internet Terms
All products >Translation Software > Flash Cards for Moblie Phones,Cell Phone Dictionary Translator. Specify language:. Albanian, Arabic, Bosnian, Bulgarian ...
[Read More]
Tracked on Apr 18, 2006 1:37:51 AM
» Legalising and declassifying drugs from What if all drugs were legal?
urban75 drug information: a huge online resource of drug information, help and advice including cannabis, cocaine, heroin, ecstasy, solvents, ketamine and ... [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 27, 2006 12:34:07 AM
» Free & Open Source Software Portal: Search from An Online Directory
Popular links · Discussion Forum. Directory Search. By Keyword. Advanced Search. Directory New Links. New links added this week. links in Portal... [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 27, 2006 1:26:55 AM
» Auto Search: 1939 chevrolet 4x4 from Online Auto Guise
Search and Compare Certified Pre-Owned Cars. Car Shopping Tools and Advice · 2006 Auto Shows · New York Auto Show Check out 2007 models and cool concepts ... [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 27, 2006 11:11:12 AM
» The Interactive NGC Catalog Online from Official Catalog
The Interactive NGC Catalog Online. This is the interactive NGC (and IC, and Messier) catalog at SEDS, based on the famous NGC 2000.0 by RW Sinnott of Sky ... [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 30, 2006 2:06:11 AM
» Epilepsy Association Sarajevo Urgent Appeal from to work, care
is a non-governmental humanitarian organization established in 2001 with the aim of providing [Read More]
Tracked on May 4, 2006 5:07:52 AM
» USA Search Engine Optimization from Advanced Search | US
Directory of USA (USA) search engine optimization (seo) and marketing professionals for web sites, internet development and viral marketing campaigns. [Read More]
Tracked on May 7, 2006 6:19:56 PM
» Italian Charms from ItalianCharms -- Search results
Italian charms has stainless links from companies by Zoppini, Boxing, ReFlorence, Puzzle, Ryry, Talexia & Unodomani... [Read More]
Tracked on May 21, 2006 3:19:46 PM
» Osteoporosis drug to protect against breast cancer from on a press release
reported three newspapers (19 April 2006). The reports are based on a press release of early results of a large clinical trial, for [Read More]
Tracked on May 21, 2006 7:54:47 PM
» Welcome to Ukrainian Gift Shop from Gifts Shop
Ukrainian Gift Shop is the world's largest source of Pysanky, Ukrainian Easter eggs, and Pysanky supplies... [Read More]
Tracked on May 23, 2006 8:45:10 AM
» Iraqi Army Taking 'Baby Steps' to Secure Country from roops Say They
roops Say They Need Better Supplies, Armor to Defeat Insurgents [Read More]
Tracked on May 25, 2006 7:11:15 AM
» Die Schweizer Suchmaschine from dir.pogovorim.com
Suchmaschine fr die Schweiz mit regionaler Volltextsuche (im domain und in weiteren Sites mit... [Read More]
Tracked on May 27, 2006 7:00:25 AM
» News Online from JapanHorse
Features weekly articles, archives to past issues, and timelines of scientific importance. [Read More]
Tracked on Jun 4, 2006 1:28:40 AM
» Internal Audit: Resources for Internal Auditors from Audit Company
Internal Audit - is the Web portal and online community for the internal audit profession provides free audit work programs, ICQ's, checklists, ...
[Read More]
Tracked on Jun 6, 2006 9:24:33 PM
» Activity in the New England Retail Market from the Greater Boston-Cambridge-Quincy,
Retail MarketPlace Data, a database that actively measures retail activity, [Read More]
Tracked on Jun 7, 2006 8:15:15 PM
» Fourteen Chefs to Cook Up Culinary Scholarships in an Extraordinary Wine Pairing Event at the Two Rivers Winery Chateau in Grand Junction from
URI: http://www.prweb.com/zingpr.php/TG92ZS1aZXRhLUhvcnItUHJvZi1IYWxmLVplcm8=
[Read More]
Tracked on Jun 8, 2006 5:51:00 AM
» consolidation loan student
from college loan
Loans Home Equity Loans - Home Mortgage Student Loans [Read More]
Tracked on Jun 18, 2006 7:51:44 PM
» Gilchrist Revives NBA Hopes After Year in Israel from spent the day
for work a little closer to home, preferably in the NBA, writes Ed Miller of the VIRGINIAN-PILOT. [Read More]
Tracked on Jul 24, 2006 5:48:58 PM
» ALL Themes from Invision Power Board
He has set up a test blog so you can check it out - it’s great work. ... Note to all theme authors: In order to be considered for the competition, ... [Read More]
Tracked on Jul 25, 2006 3:50:27 PM
» Internet Statistic: loop isolation from Words 2006
Most Popular Words 2006... [Read More]
Tracked on Aug 1, 2006 2:43:08 AM
» Wiki: Search Results from MostDor
Search Results · WelcomeVisitors . . . . . . WhatIsWiki WhatIsWiki . . . . . . WhatIsWiki. 2 pages found out of 22 pages searched. ... [Read More]
Tracked on Aug 4, 2006 7:05:24 AM
» Bvlgari from Bvlgari Watches
Great Saving On Bvlgari Watches Bulgari Watch Bvlgari Assioma, Bulgari Zero1, Bulgari Watch Tubagas, Bvlgari Diagono Aluminium, ...
[Read More]
Tracked on Aug 9, 2006 9:17:34 PM
» Энциклопедия рунета from Internet Search
Выберите интересующий Вас раздел: 0-9 B C D E F G H I L M O R S T V W А Б В Г Д Е Ж З И К Л М Н О П Р С Т У Ф Х Ц Ч Ш Щ Э Ю Я TOP 20... [Read More]
Tracked on Aug 15, 2006 10:12:25 AM
